When I Work is a low-cost, mobile-first employee scheduling and time-tracking app for hourly teams, with shift swaps, availability, and messaging that staff can manage from their phones. Its per-user pricing makes it easy to start, and it now offers payroll and HR add-ons.
Businesses look elsewhere when they want a free tier, deeper labor-compliance features, richer reporting, or a full payroll and HR platform rather than a scheduling-first tool. These eight When I Work alternatives span both cheaper scheduling apps and more complete workforce platforms.
TL;DR
| Tool | Starting price | Rating | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gusto | $35/mo | ★ 4.6 | Teams that want real payroll and benefits alongside their scheduling. |
| Rippling | $8/mo | ★ 4.9 | Scaling companies that want one unified platform. |
| Paylocity | Custom | ★ 4.4 | Larger organizations that want full HCM. |
| RUN Powered by ADP | Custom | ★ 4.6 | Employers that want an established payroll provider alongside scheduling. |
| BambooHR | $10/mo | ★ 4.4 | Teams that want strong HR software beyond scheduling. |
| Paychex Flex | $39/mo | ★ 4.2 | Businesses that want a payroll rep alongside scheduling. |
| Sling | Free scheduling for up to about 30 users; Premium from $1.70 per user/mo. | — | Budget teams that want free scheduling for a small crew. |
| Connecteam | Free Small Business plan for up to 10 users; paid plans from about $29/mo for up to 30 users billed annually. | — | Deskless teams that want an all-in-one operations app. |
Best for real payroll and benefits
What it does better than When I Work
Gusto delivers full-service payroll, benefits, and HR far beyond When I Work's payroll add-on, with no per-run fee, and it integrates to import scheduled or tracked hours.
Where When I Work still wins
Gusto has no native shift scheduling for hourly teams.
Best for: Teams that want real payroll and benefits alongside their scheduling.
Best for one unified workforce platform
What it does better than When I Work
Rippling's time and scheduling module sits inside a full HR, IT, and payroll platform with heavy automation, scaling well past When I Work.
Where When I Work still wins
It is pricier, quote-based, and more complex than a scheduling-first small team needs.
Best for: Scaling companies that want one unified platform.
Best for mid-market hourly teams
What it does better than When I Work
Paylocity is a full HCM with scheduling, time, payroll, and strong engagement tools for mid-market hourly teams.
Where When I Work still wins
It is quote-based, pricier, and a heavier implementation than When I Work.
Best for: Larger organizations that want full HCM.
Best for established payroll to pair with scheduling
What it does better than When I Work
ADP brings established payroll, tax filing, and benefits at scale that When I Work's add-ons can't match.
Where When I Work still wins
It has no scheduling focus and is pricier and quote-based.
Best for: Employers that want an established payroll provider alongside scheduling.
Best for adding a polished HRIS
What it does better than When I Work
BambooHR is a polished HRIS with onboarding, PTO, and performance management that When I Work lacks, plus a large integration ecosystem.
Where When I Work still wins
It is not a scheduling or time-clock tool for shift work.
Best for: Teams that want strong HR software beyond scheduling.
Best for a payroll rep with room to grow
What it does better than When I Work
Paychex offers dedicated support and a services ladder up to full HR and PEO that a scheduling app doesn't provide.
Where When I Work still wins
It has no native scheduling and is quote-based.
Best for: Businesses that want a payroll rep alongside scheduling.
Best for free scheduling on a budget
What it does better than When I Work
Sling offers a genuinely free plan for up to about 30 users with solid scheduling, messaging, and task features, undercutting When I Work on price.
Where When I Work still wins
When I Work has a more polished mobile experience, deeper time-clock and attendance features, and a native payroll add-on.
Best for: Budget teams that want free scheduling for a small crew.
Best for deskless all-in-one operations
What it does better than When I Work
Connecteam bundles scheduling with communication, checklists, training, and HR hubs for deskless teams, going broader than When I Work's scheduling focus.
Where When I Work still wins
It has no native US payroll, and its flat pricing can exceed When I Work's per-user model at very small headcounts.
Best for: Deskless teams that want an all-in-one operations app.
More on our approach on the About page.
Answer a few quick questions and we'll recommend the right tools for your business, budget, and team.